A fresh wave of public anger has swept across social media after Calvince Okoth, popularly known as Gaucho, livestreamed a ward tour at Mama Lucy Kibaki Hospital on TikTok, capturing images and videos of patients in vulnerable states without their apparent consent.
Gaucho, whose recent appointment to the hospital’s board by Nairobi Governor Johnson Sakaja drew widespread criticism over his qualifications and background, had joined other board members on an inspection of the facility.
As the group walked through the corridors, interacting with staff and patients, he switched to live mode on his TikTok account, broadcasting the scenes in real time to hundreds of viewers.
Viewers, nearly a thousand watching simultaneously, saw individuals resting in beds, a person cradling a newborn, and at least one patient visibly in distress, leaning against a wall for support.
Gaucho was seen occasionally glancing back, apparently checking whether his recording was continuing.
The episode has drawn condemnation online, with many Kenyans arguing it represents a clear breach of patient privacy and medical ethics. Critics compared the actions to violations that would trigger strict penalties under U.S. HIPAA regulations, which tightly control the use and disclosure of protected health information.
One X user, Gathogo Mwangi, wrote: “An equivalent of HIPAA laws should apply in Kenya heavily. Patient privacy is nothing one should play with at all. What do you mean you are moving with cameras in a ward!”
Others questioned the purpose of the unannounced walkthrough and the decision to film in active clinical areas where nurses were attending to urgent duties. “Why is he even here in the first place? What does Gaucho’s presence in a female ward help with?” asked Robert Mwanza. “These busybodies have no business colliding with qualified nurses on their official duties.”
Health and gender activist Dr Bosire Wairimu publicly asked why the appointee appeared unfamiliar with basic patient-privacy rules, tagging government health officials and data-protection authorities and describing the incident as potentially criminal.
Legal and ethical context
Patient privacy and confidentiality in Kenya are protected under the Constitution of Kenya (2010), the Data Protection Act (2019), and the Health Act (2017).
Health information is classified as sensitive personal data, and its processing or sharing generally requires informed consent. Section 11 of the Health Act permits disclosure of confidential patient information only with written consent, by court order, or in specific public health emergencies.
The Office of the Data Protection Commissioner (ODPC) is responsible for enforcing these rules.
Many commentators have called for stricter oversight and clearer guidelines for public officials and board members operating in healthcare settings.
Leave a comment