Bloggers to challenge constitutionality of new law - Business Today News
Connect with us

Media Watch

Bloggers to challenge constitutionality of new law

BAKE holds that several provisions of the law not only infringe on the Constitution but also international standards and statutes on freedom of expression and freedom of the media



The Bloggers Association of Kenya (BAKE) has criticised Computer Misuse and Cybercrimes Act, 2018, which was signed into law by President Uhuru Kenyatta on Wednesday, terming it retrogressive to a country that espouses, defends and thrives in media freedoms.

In a statement, BAKE held that several provisions of the law not only infringe on the Constitution but also international standards and statutes on freedom of expression and freedom of the media.

Specifically, BAKE expressed great concern over the following sections, stating what it finds problematic;

  1. a)Section 3 (d) on the Objectives of the Act negates the very purpose it seeks to enhance. In many ways, this law fails to protect rights to privacy, freedom of expression and freedom of information.
  2. b)The National Computer and Cybercrimes Coordination Committee lacks oversight in its representation as it is solely from government. Industry needs representation to articulate and advance stakeholder interests. The Director who shall be the secretary to the committee lacks a vote meaning he or she will only take direction from committee members who are heads or appointees of the respective government agencies.
  3. c)Section 16 and 17 that touch on unauthorized interception, unauthorized access and unauthorized interference are meant to stifle whistle blowing culture and practice in the country. It should be reminded that that the embezzlements at Chase Bank and National Bank would not have been made public were it not for Kenyans of goodwill who provided the information to Kenyans online. While high ranking government officials blamed bloggers for publishing and sharing the information, some even calling for the regulation of bloggers, the information was accurate. It came to pass and relevant authorities are today investigation and in some cases, like National Bank, found and fined the culpable individuals. These sections will curtail public vigilance and throttle free access of information, necessary to protect public trust, grow our democracy and ensure corrupt individuals are put behind bars.
  4. d)Section 22, while seeking to address fake news, or false publication which is an international growing concern, defining what constitutes ‘false’ is problematic. It is not only problematic that the Act fails to define it, but also in practice, giving fertile grounds for individuals in power to use and misuse it to arrest, intimidate and threaten bloggers and Kenyans online. In addition, having a penalty of Ksh 5 million and two years’ imprisonment is meant to stifle freedom of expression. Punitive provisions are often used to bully people from enjoying rights they have.
  5. e)Section 23 on publication of false information lacks clarity. What the state for all its intent and purpose could define as possibly causing panic could be regarded by the general public as ridicule and genuine criticism. In addition, it can be satirical, for instance by cartoonists. Good governance including political accountability and transparency issues that Kenyans yearn for will soon be a thing of the past if this provision is unchecked.
  6. f)Section 37 on wrongful distribution of obscene or intimate images fails to comply with limitations on freedom of expression. It seeks to create new limitations not contemplated in the Constitution.

BAKE reiterated that freedom of expression is not absolute, pointing out that Article 33 (2) expressly provides that the right does not extend to propaganda for war; incitement to violence; hate speech; or advocacy of hatred. It says these are the legal limitations that any Statute must respect.

“It should be noted that the High Court found Section 29 of the Kenya Information and Communications Act unconstitutional for lack of definition of the key operative words like “indecent”, “obscene”, “anxiety” among others. Justice Mumbi Ngugi asserted that “the words are so wide and vague that their meaning will depend on the subjective interpretation of which officer (police, prosecutor, and magistrate),” the statement said.

In this Act, BAKE says, words like ‘false’, ‘panic’, ‘obscene’, ‘misleading’, and ‘fictitious data’, cannot pass the legal test.


“While there are other provisions that are vague and need redress, these ones listed directly affect bloggers. We must guard our hard-earned rights and freedoms. Kenyans must stand up to protect, defend and uphold the Constitution as Article 3 expects,” said BAKE Chairman Kennedy Kachwanya.

In view of the above, the association said it has engaged a lawyer with the intention of challenging this law as soon as possible. “The chilling effect this law portends needs to be arrested,” Kachwanya added.

Business Today is the leading independent online business website in Kenya. Started in 2012 by a veteran business journalist, it has a huge following both in Kenya and abroad. It covers various business and related issues. Email editor at: [email protected]

Click to comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

News Updates

NEWS22 hours ago

British pensioner guilty of Kenya ‘holiday ‘ rape charges

The Crown Prosecution Service (CPS) said Keith Morris, 72, befriended the young victims' families over the past 20 years, giving...

Health2 days ago

US surrogacy agency withdraws from ‘perilous’ Kenya

Sensible Surrogacy now recommends new lower-cost programmes in the United States, which it says are completely safe and have the...

NEWS2 days ago

Kenya to reform laws to enhance biodiversity conservation

Tobiko says the ministry of Environment has formulated and reviewed laws and regulations to implement the provisions of the constitution...

Education3 days ago

Endowment Fund for Alliance High School launched

Fund targets to raise at least KSh 5 billion under the endowment funds, between now and 2026, the year the...

NEWS3 days ago

Uganda PM, Wangamati forge closer ties

Drawing from their proximity and shared culture including common language, Governor Wycliffe Wangamati said the two regions are in fact...

NEWS6 days ago

Youth PS Lillian Omollo, NYS chief Ndubai quit

State House Spokesman Manoah Esipisu says President Uhuru Kenyatta accepted the offer by the two officers to step aside for...

NEWS6 days ago

Police issue alert over emerging cult

Directorate of Criminal Investigations says the cult, known as Young Blud Saints, believes that there are three gods namely: true...

NEWS7 days ago

Cyprian Nyakundi released on DPP’s orders

Noordin Haji had also directed that no further criminal charges relating to the application should be registered against the blogger...

Politics7 days ago

I’m not boarding, Miguna tells Sonko

Nairobi County Assembly Speaker Beatrice Elachi had confirmed receiving Sonko's letter but asked him to regularise his Kenyan citizenship, a...

NEWS1 week ago

Patel finally speaks, pledges support for victims

Family says it continues to address immediate humanitarian concerns, providing food and nutrition, clean drinking water, healthcare and basic household...