The Court of Appeal has overturned the ruling by the Employment and Labour Relations Court that had awarded close to Sh1 billion in compensation to former National Bank of Kenya employees for wrongful termination.
The former employees had moved to court in early 2014, seeking damages for unfair retirement and discrimination under the Voluntary Early Retirement (VER) scheme offered by the bank.
They said the bank accepted their VER on terms that were not only discriminatory, but in breach of the bank’s Human Resource (HR) Manual, Collective Bargaining Agreement (CBA), and the Constitution and the Employment Act 2007.
In her judgment delivered on February 22, 2017, Justice Monica Mbaru of the Employment and Labour Relations Court stated that the former employees were discriminated against and unfairly treated when they were sent on voluntary retirement in 2014.
“To engage an employee on inferior or unfavourable terms and conditions of employment is a practice that cannot find justification in law and in fair labour practices. Such should be frowned upon and not receive the sanction of the court,” she said.
Through its lawyers Mr Chacha Odera of Oraro and Co. Advocates, the bank appealed the ruling stating that the offer made to the claimants was not discriminatory. The bank also faulted the ruling for not appreciating that VER agreement was separate and distinct from the HR manual and CBA.
“They have failed to illustrate or establish factual and legal comparable terms against which the offer is discriminatory,” NBK said in its response. “The respondents were bound by the terms of the VER scheme and it was not open to the learned Judge to rewrite the contract as she did,” the bank said in response to the trial court ruling.”
In their ruling, appellate judges Alnashir Visram, W. Karanja and M.K. Koome stated that the respondents accepted the terms offered in the circular according to their respective applications as well as acceptance letters issued by the bank, adding that it was open for the respondents to reject the aforesaid terms and not take advantage of the VER scheme.
“In our view, there was no evidence of undue influence or coercion which diminished the respondents’ capacity to voluntarily accept the terms in question.”
“Moreover, it is clear that the parties vide the circular, applications and acceptance letters varied the terms of retirement as stipulated in the HR manual and CBA. We find that the appeal has merit and hereby allowed with costs to the appellant. We hereby set aside the judgment of the trial court dated 22ndFebruary 2017 and substitute the same with an order dismissing the respondents’ suit with cost to appellant,” Judgment reads in part.
In 2014, National Bank of Kenya launched a voluntary early retirement scheme for employees aged 50 years and above as part of its restructuring process geared towards achieving its growth target as spelt out in its strategic plan 2013-2017.
Young sociologist who heads health docket in Turkana
Moses Natome, who has been re-nominated by Governor Josphat Nanok, says he a team player and has in the past...
Kenya faces Sh103b annual shortfall for universal health coverage
Health PS Julius Korir says so far the government is only able to afford Ksh 12.4 billion annually to cater...
Supreme Court explains why it threw out petitions
The court ruled that NASA candidate Raila Odinga did not formally withdraw from the election but only declared his intention to withdraw
Time Raila stopped being a political enigma
Election seasons must be predictable so that the people and their chosen government can move on with the business of nation...
Nairobi-based US diplomat quits, blasts Trump
In a scathing resignation letter, Elizabeth Shackelford tore into the Trump administration and Secretary of State Rex Tillerson for undermining the work...
Half of Govt workers are drug addicts
NACADA survey shows alcohol abuse among employees in the public sector stands at 57.9 percent, higher than the national average...
Kenya’s economy to ‘bounce back’
Kenya’s economy is set to grow from the current 4.9% to 5.5% and 5.9% in 2018 and 2019 respectively, a...
Libya slavery scam: Africa has killed its own sun
African states have created the environment in their home countries that have made their citizenry so desperate and hopeless to...
Unique name that inspired KCPE star
As a biology teacher, Harrison Tanga was not fazed when he went to hospital to see his newborn child, unlike...
Youth turn to sex to soothe election pain
The struggle to make ends meet has left them disillusioned, apathetic and angry, according to the annual survey of nearly...