For NYT journalist, terror from gory photos

The New York Times tagline is ‘All the News That’s Fit to Print’ but incoming East Africa Bureau Chief Kimiko de Freytas Tamura must be calling for a different approach while reporting on Kenya after learning the hard way that Kenyans can be a very unforgiving lot when it comes to emotional issues.

On Tuesday, Kenyans were up in arms against Ms Tamura over the publisher’s decision to embed gory photos of the Riverside Attack victims in her story.

The rage that ensued was ungovernable; she was all alone in an online war against a multitude of Kenyans on Twitter and Facebook in a fight she later said she did not instigate.

Kenyans demanded the offensive photos be pulled down and an explanation on why they were used. Ms Tamura on the other hand maintained that she was only the writer and played no part in the selection of the photos. She advised Kenyans to direct their anger to the NYT photo department in a Tweet that was later pulled down.

The rest, you would say, is history.

Ms Tamura is not new in Kenya and Africa at large, though. She reported on the nullification of President Uhuru Kenyatta’s election in September 2017 and also wrote a feature on the Ethiopian government’s network of spies on November 5 2017.

READ: ARROGANT NEW YORK TIMES FAILS TO LEARN FROM CNN, FOX BLUNDERS

But she is more popular for an article she wrote on January 14 this year on the Democratic Republic of Congo (DRC) politics detailing how, despite the election of Felix Tshisekedi, immediate former President Joseph Kabila is still calling the shots.

It is fair to say that she is built for NYT East Africa Bureau Chief job; she is familiar with the region’s politics and has crisscrossed Africa in pursuit of stories with a global appeal.

But none of that will matter to Kenyans who have already called for her deportation. And that is because they strongly believe that the gory photos were not fit to print.

Ethics on trial

An in-house assessment by Business Today of Tamura’s NYT articles portray her as an independent journalist. She has written a lot of articles ranging from politics, business and crime.

SEE ALSO: QUALITY JOURNALISM PUSHES NEW YORK TIMES SUBSCRIPTIONS TO RECORD HIGH

BBC broadcast reporter Flora Drury in an analysis of the Riverside Attack article published on Wednesday questioned whether it was ethical for NYT to publish the photos.

According to the British broadcaster, the attack at the 14 Riverside complex wasn’t over when the picture of the dead men slumped over the tables in the Nairobi restaurant where they had been having lunch was published.

“The decision of a number of US and European outlets – including the UK’s MailOnline and Germany’s Bild – to use the photograph was instantly condemned on Kenyan social media. The New York Times came in for the most criticism,” Drury wrote.

“The newspaper, angry users said, was using the “misery and tragedy” of Tuesday’s terror attack on the Dusit hotel for clickbait,” said the BBC article.

BBC added that the speed with which the picture was published meant many were still unaware their loved ones had been caught up in the attack.

READ : NEW YORK TIMES JOURNALIST STARING AT EXPULSION IN KENYA

BBC ended the article saying it had sought New York Times for comment.

Similarly, The Poynter Institute for Media Studies, a non profit school of journalism based in Florida also waded into the debate questioning whether the Times was justified in publishing the photos.

“While the controversy involving the photo pales in comparison to the awful tragedy, the Times’ decision to run the photo brings up the ethical question that editors everywhere grapple with any time there is a horrific event,” Poynter said.

The Media Studies school went on to defend the decision by the Times to publish the photo, saying the American newspaper has an obligation to give its readers a clear picture of the horror.

“This photo absolutely showed the devastation caused by this attack and, even though it didn’t show the faces of the deceased, the images of two people whose lives ended while sitting in a restaurant humanized the tragedy in a way no words could. That right there is the strongest case to run the photo.”

Poynter concluded, “Is this a tough image? Yes, no question. But should the Times have run it? Yes, no question.”

Meanwhile, the Media Council of Kenya has written condemning the publishing of those photos and threatening to revoke the accreditation of NYT journalists locally.

The NYT has written back to Kenya’s media watchdog, in a battle that looks set to continue.

SEE ALSO : 14 RIVERSIDE MANAGEMENT SPEAKS OUT AFTER TERROR ATTACK

Latest

In Race for African Leadership Award, Ruto Faces Tough Opposition

Among the contenders of the prestigious African of the Year award is Kenya’s President William Ruto, who will be battling it out with President Hakainde Hichilema of Zambia and Prof. Benedict Okey Oramah, President of Afrexim Bank.

Transforming Financial Inclusion: The Impact of M-Pesa in Kenya and Beyond 

Discover the profound impact of M-Pesa on financial inclusion in Kenya and beyond. Explore how this innovative mobile service revolutionizes transactions and shapes the future of finance globally.

All You Need To Know About Vaping

Vaping, the act of inhaling vapour produced by an...

A Look at New Generation Ford Vehicle Models Trending in Kenya

The new partnership between Ford and Caetano offers the brand an opportunity to gain market share in Kenya by leveraging on Caetano’s extensive network and experience.

Follow Us

Newsletter

Don't miss

Safaricom To Power Tusker OktobaFest Beer Festival

Safaricom’s involvement in OktobaFest as a technology and payments partner will focus on fostering seamless in-festival connectivity, empowering the youth and Gen Z community through Safaricom Hook, and powering digital payments through M-PESA.

Music Producers Launch Organization To Streamline Recording Industry

Recording Industry of Kenya (RIKE) was launched on 9th October 2023. Registered in 2022 as a not-for-profit organization, RIKE aims to promote the collective interests of producers of sound recordings in the country.

Nairobi’s Hero Bar Listed Among World’s 50 Best Bars

World Best Bars: Hero Bar in Nairobi continues to climb the list, moving up six places to No.62 and Johannesburg’s Sin + Tax comes in at No.94. Dubai new entry Ergo is at No.69 and Melbourne’s Byrdi has re-entered the list at No.61.

Kenyan DJs Face Off In Smirnoff Battle Of The Beats Season 3

The Smirnoff Battle of the Beats Season 3, a DJ competition, is poised to unleash an unprecedented musical frenzy countrywide.

The Highs And Lows Of Betty Kyallo, Sisters Show As Season 2 Ends

Kyallo Kulture has always been, above all, about sisterhood, and in Season 2 we have witnessed the charm of it - the ups that gave us wholesome moments as the sisters led by Betty Kyallo spent time together.

DStv Beats CNN, BBC To Become Most Admired Media Outlet In Africa

DStv, MultiChoice Group’s leading broadcast service, has been named...

MultiChoice Revises Subscription Fees For DStv, GOtv

MultiChoice has announced price adjustments on some of their...

Octopizzo: How I Make My Money

"I've been doing this for 12, 13 years. It reaches a point where you no longer need to prove that you can make a hit record," he stated.

New Spotify EQUAL Artist Qing Madi Talks Music and Dreams

Heavily influenced by her cultural background and the lyrical arrangements of Kendrick Lamar, the versatile Nigerian prodigy is shaping the future of music with her unique genre-bending fusion of Afrobeats, Pop, Soul and R&B.

Bob Collymore Immortalized in New Festival

The late Collymore was famous for his love for jazz and even initiated the Safaricom Jazz Festival, which saw several of the world's biggest Jazz artists perform in Nairobi.

In Race for African Leadership Award, Ruto Faces Tough Opposition

Among the contenders of the prestigious African of the Year award is Kenya’s President William Ruto, who will be battling it out with President Hakainde Hichilema of Zambia and Prof. Benedict Okey Oramah, President of Afrexim Bank.

Transforming Financial Inclusion: The Impact of M-Pesa in Kenya and Beyond 

Discover the profound impact of M-Pesa on financial inclusion in Kenya and beyond. Explore how this innovative mobile service revolutionizes transactions and shapes the future of finance globally.

All You Need To Know About Vaping

Vaping, the act of inhaling vapour produced by an electronic cigarette or similar device, has a relatively short history compared to traditional tobacco smoking. The...

10 COMMENTS

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here